Best Italian Restaurants in Hartford
Curated guide featuring 7 outstanding restaurants, all rated 4.5+ stars
Hartford's Italian dining scene punches well above its weight, offering everything from old-school red-sauce joints that have been family favorites for generations to sleek modern trattorias serving up innovative takes on classic dishes. What sets this city apart is the authenticity you'll find here – many of these restaurants are run by families who've been perfecting their recipes for decades, and you can taste that dedication in every bite. Whether you're craving a perfectly al dente pasta, wood-fired pizza with blistered crust, or veal that melts on your fork, Hartford's Italian restaurants deliver with remarkable consistency.
This guide brings together 10 of the highest-rated Italian restaurants in the Hartford area, each one earning at least 4.5 stars from diners who know their carbonara from their cacio e pepe. We're talking about places where the average rating sits at an impressive 4.6 stars across thousands of reviews – that's not hype, that's proof these spots are doing something right. From intimate date-night destinations to lively spots perfect for family gatherings, you'll find options for every occasion and appetite, all united by their commitment to serving exceptional Italian food.
Featured Restaurants
Salute
Located in the heart of downtown Hartford, Salute has earned its stellar 4.7-star rating from thousands of diners who appreciate its diverse menu offerings and welcoming atmosphere. With such consistently high marks across nearly 2,500 reviews, travelers can count on quality food and reliable service whether they're looking for a business lunch or casual dinner. Given its prime Trumbull Street location, it's an ideal spot to fuel up before or after exploring Hartford's cultural attractions, and the mid-range pricing makes it accessible for most budgets.
Restaurant Bricco
This West Hartford gem has earned its stellar 4.6-star rating from over 1,300 diners who rave about its welcoming atmosphere and consistently delicious food across multiple cuisines. Travelers appreciate the mid-range pricing that delivers exceptional quality without breaking the bank, making it a reliable choice whether you're looking for a casual dinner or special occasion meal. Given its popularity in the LaSalle Road dining scene, consider making a reservation ahead of time, especially for weekend evenings.
Treva
Treva has earned its stellar reputation among over 1,200 diners as West Hartford's go-to spot for elevated bar fare and craft cocktails in a lively, welcoming atmosphere. Travelers consistently praise the quality-to-price ratio at this mid-range gem, making it perfect for both casual drinks and full meals without breaking the bank. Arrive during happy hour to snag the best deals, or swing by on weekends when the energy is at its peak and the bar scene really comes alive.
First and Last Tavern Hartford
This beloved Hartford institution has earned its stellar reputation with over 900 glowing reviews, drawing locals and visitors alike for its welcoming tavern atmosphere and diverse menu that offers something for everyone. The consistently high ratings speak to reliable quality and friendly service that keeps people coming back, making it a safe bet whether you're craving comfort food classics or looking to try something new. Given its popularity, consider visiting during off-peak hours to snag a table more easily, or embrace the lively crowd that's part of this neighborhood favorite's charm.
Salute
Salute has earned its stellar 4.7-star reputation from over 500 diners who appreciate its welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu that offers something for everyone. Travelers consistently praise this mid-range gem for delivering quality food and reliable service that keeps locals and visitors coming back. With its strong track record, you can confidently stop in for lunch or dinner, though calling ahead on weekends is wise given its popularity in the Rocky Hill area.
Adriatic Restaurant
This highly-rated Hartford gem serves up a diverse menu that keeps locals and travelers coming back, as evidenced by nearly 300 glowing reviews. The welcoming atmosphere and consistently quality food at reasonable prices make it a reliable choice when you want a satisfying meal without breaking the bank. With such a strong rating, you can feel confident ordering any of their popular dishes, though arriving during off-peak hours ensures the best service and a more relaxed dining experience.
Lenoci's Italian Kitchen
Lenoci's Italian Kitchen has earned a devoted following in historic Wethersfield, with an impressive 4.7-star rating from over 200 diners who praise its welcoming atmosphere and satisfying Italian fare. Travelers consistently rave about the quality and generous portions, making it a reliable choice whether you're craving classic pasta dishes or exploring their diverse menu offerings. For the best experience, consider making reservations during peak dinner hours, as this popular neighborhood spot fills up quickly with both locals and visitors.
Culinary Experiences in Hartford
Discover food tours, cooking classes, and unique dining experiences